The Eastleigh Building Collapse: Who Bears Responsibility When Public Safety Is Compromised?

By Hansen Advocates

Introduction: Beyond the Rubble Lies a Question of Accountability

The tragic building collapse in Eastleigh, Nairobi, has once again exposed the risks associated with construction, regulatory compliance and accountability in Kenya’s real estate sector. As rescue operations continue and investigations seek to establish what went wrong, an important question arises: Who should take responsibility when a building collapses and innocent people pay the price?

In our view, responsibility cannot be confined to the contractor who physically undertook the construction. It must be examined across the entire development chain, including the developer, construction professionals and public authorities mandated to regulate and enforce building standards.

One principle must, however, remain clear: the primary responsibility for delivering a safe and legally compliant development rests with the developer. Regulatory approvals do not absolve a developer of the responsibility to ensure that a project is properly executed.

1. The Developer Must Answer First

A developer is not merely an investor providing land and capital. The developer is the central party responsible for initiating, organising and delivering the project. This includes ensuring that the necessary development permissions are obtained, qualified professionals are engaged, construction standards are observed and the building is safe for its intended use.

Reports concerning Eastleigh have raised questions about the project’s approvals, construction arrangements and occupation status.

These matters must be investigated thoroughly. A developer cannot simply transfer responsibility to an architect, engineer or contractor. Engaging professionals is part of responsible development; it does not eliminate the developer’s own obligations.

2. Construction Professionals Must Be Accountable

Architects, structural engineers and contractors have distinct professional and contractual responsibilities. Structural integrity is not achieved by drawings and approvals alone. It depends on competent design, appropriate materials, quality workmanship and proper supervision throughout construction.

The investigation must establish whether the project was executed in accordance with approved designs, whether the professionals identified actually undertook their respective roles and whether applicable construction standards were observed.

Professional accountability must go beyond having a name, stamp or registration number appearing in project documents.

3. Where Was the Regulator?

The role of Nairobi City County and other regulatory institutions deserves equally serious scrutiny.

Public statements by the Governor indicated that although a change of user had been approved, the subsequent architectural and building plans had not received the necessary approval. The Governor also indicated that enforcement officers had previously flagged the construction.

This raises legitimate questions: If the development was proceeding without the requisite approvals, what enforcement action was taken? Were stop orders issued and enforced? How did the development progress to a stage where premises were reportedly occupied?

These questions are not accusations against individual county officials. They are questions of institutional accountability. A regulator’s responsibility does not end with issuing approvals. It extends to identifying non-compliance and taking effective enforcement action.

The public should not have to wait for a building to collapse before discovering that regulatory safeguards may have failed.

4. Real Estate Investment Must Go Beyond Land Ownership and Projected Returns

The Eastleigh incident carries an important lesson for property developers, investors and financial institutions.

Real estate development is often evaluated through land value, construction costs, rental yields and anticipated returns. However, a commercially attractive project may still be fundamentally flawed if it lacks the necessary approvals, professional oversight or structural integrity.

This is why legal due diligence must go beyond checking a title deed. Before committing capital, investors should verify ownership, permitted land use, development approvals, environmental compliance, construction arrangements and the applicable requirements for occupation. The Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019, the National Construction Authority Act and the National Building Code, 2024, provide important safeguards that developers must take seriously.

Compliance is not an unnecessary project expense. It is an investment in the safety, security and long-term value of the development.

5. Project Financing: What Exactly Are We Financing?

There is another dimension that deserves attention: the responsibility of financiers.

Banks, SACCOs, private investors and other institutions should not evaluate real estate projects solely on the value of the underlying land or projected rental income. A financier may hold a charge over valuable property, but that security does not automatically make the development legally compliant, structurally sound or commercially viable.

We believe responsible project financing should incorporate:

  1. Legal and technical due diligence before disbursement.
  2. Verification of statutory approvals and licences.
  3. Independent monitoring of construction progress.
  4. Disbursement of funds against verified project milestones.
  5. Appropriate construction and professional indemnity insurance.
  6. Properly documented financing and security arrangements.

These safeguards protect both the financier and the developer. They also help identify problems before they become expensive disputes or irreversible losses. Financing should follow verified compliance and progress, not merely the developer’s funding requirements.

6. Our Take: Accountability Must Be Established at Every Level

In our considered view, the developer bears primary responsibility for ensuring that a project is lawfully undertaken and safe for its intended use. Contractors and construction professionals must account for their respective technical and contractual obligations. Regulatory authorities must answer for the effectiveness of their oversight and enforcement.

Where negligence, professional misconduct, breach of statutory obligations or criminal conduct is established, the responsible parties must face the appropriate legal consequences. However, accountability must be evidence-based. Being associated with a project or appearing in its records does not, by itself, establish liability for a building collapse.

The investigations must establish not only what caused the building to collapse, but also whether the tragedy could reasonably have been prevented.

7. Building More Than Structures: The Hansen Advocates Approach

A real estate investment should create value, not expose investors to avoidable legal, financial and regulatory risks. At Hansen Advocates LLP, we work with developers, investors and financiers to ensure that the legal foundations of their projects are as solid as the structures they intend to build. From acquiring land and securing development approvals to structuring joint ventures, negotiating construction agreements and arranging project financing, we help turn property ambitions into legally sound investments.

Conclusion: Build Responsibly. Finance Prudently. Invest Confidently.

The Eastleigh tragedy reminds us that the true cost of a poorly managed development may extend far beyond financial loss. Human lives cannot be reduced to project costs, and public safety must never become a casualty of commercial ambition. Kenya needs more investment in real estate, but it needs investment built on compliance, professional accountability and effective regulation.

HANSEN ADVOCATES LLP

Real Estate | Project Financing | Corporate & Commercial Law

Flamingo Towers, 4th Floor, Wing A, Mara Road, Upperhill, Nairobi.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general legal education and professional commentary. It does not constitute a finding of liability against any person or entity. The circumstances surrounding the Eastleigh collapse remain subject to investigation and due process.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hansen Omido, CPM
Founding Partner

 

Hansen Omido, CPM, is the Founding Partner of Hansen Advocates LLP and an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya with extensive experience in corporate and commercial law, dispute resolution, real estate and project financing, banking and financial services, succession and estate planning, mediation, public policy development, and legal research. He combines strong legal acumen with strategic commercial insight to deliver practical, commercially sound, and high-impact legal solutions to businesses, investors, financial institutions, and individuals.

As the Founding Partner of Hansen Advocates LLP, Hansen provides strategic leadership and direction to the firm, championing a culture of professional excellence, integrity, innovation, and client-focused service. His vision is anchored in building a progressive legal practice that goes beyond conventional legal representation to create lasting value for clients, institutions, and the wider community.

Hansen has built a diverse and impactful legal career, having worked with leading law firms, including MAK & Partners Advocates LLP, Mosioma & Co. Advocates, and Ashitiva Advocates LLP. These experiences have enabled him to develop deep expertise in corporate advisory, real estate transactions, dispute resolution, and financial sector legal services, establishing him as a trusted legal advisor and strategic partner to a diverse clientele.

His experience includes leading the restructuring of companies with a combined asset base exceeding Kshs. 800 million, developing and advising on family trust structures holding assets worth over USD 20 million, and overseeing complex real estate and development projects valued at more than Kshs. 3 billion. Notably, he structured and provided legal oversight for a Kshs. 400 million residential development project for Kenya Airways staff, supporting regulatory compliance, transaction efficiency, risk mitigation, and effective project execution.

In banking and financial services, Hansen has extensive experience in the perfection of securities, structuring of transactions, and advising on complex commercial arrangements. His work has involved leading financial institutions, including KCB Bank, Kingdom Bank, Victoria Commercial Bank, UNFCU, and UNSACCO. He also advises and represents financial institutions in commercial transactions, recovery proceedings, and complex disputes, bringing together legal precision, commercial awareness, and a practical understanding of financial risk.

Beyond commercial practice, Hansen is committed to access to justice, human rights, and public interest advocacy. He has provided pro bono legal representation in matters involving gender-based violence, discrimination against persons living with HIV, and other vulnerable groups. This commitment reflects his conviction that the law should serve not only as an instrument of commercial certainty but also as a means of protecting rights, promoting fairness, and advancing social justice.

Hansen also contributes to sports governance and institutional development. He serves as Chairman of Stingers Rugby Club and Secretary to the Kenya Rugby Union Constitution Review Committee, roles through which he contributes to governance reform, institutional strengthening, and policy development within Kenyan rugby.

He holds a Bachelor of Laws (LL.B), a Postgraduate Diploma in Law, and a Master of Arts in International Relations and Diplomacy. He is also a Certified Professional Mediator (CPM), complementing his legal practice with expertise in negotiation, conflict resolution, and alternative dispute resolution.

Away from the boardroom, courtroom, and demands of legal practice, Hansen has a creative side that may surprise many: he is a skilled rapper with a passion for music and lyrical expression. This distinctive blend of legal intellect, strategic thinking, leadership, and creativity reflects a personality that is as dynamic as it is grounded.

For Hansen, building a successful legal practice is about more than transactions, disputes, or professional recognition. It is about building institutions, cultivating meaningful relationships, and creating enduring value. Through his leadership at Hansen Advocates LLP, he continues to pursue a vision of legal practice defined by excellence, integrity, innovation, and lasting impact.

Email

hansen@hansenadvocates.com

This will close in 0 seconds

Njiule Wakoli, DPO
Partner 

 

Njiule Wakoli, DPO, is an accomplished Advocate of the High Court of Kenya and a dynamic legal practitioner with extensive experience delivering tailored legal solutions across East Africa. He holds a Bachelor of Laws (LLB) from Mount Kenya University, a Post Graduate Diploma in Law from the Kenya School of Law, and specialized certifications in IP Law from the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and Data Protection from Strathmore University.

Throughout his career, Njiule has built a robust professional background through impactful roles in public and private institutions. He has served as a Bench Legal Researcher at the Rent Restriction Tribunal in Nairobi, a corporate agent and legal assistant at Elegant Investments 1996 Limited, and gained early experience at Chege Kibathi & Co. Advocates and the High Court of Kenya. Notably, he has acted as lead counsel in landmark public interest cases successfully reviewing the jurisdiction of select Kenyan tribunals, and was recognized in 2023 as the best upcoming litigator and debater before Lord Baron Burnett of Maldon, the Chief Justice of England and Wales.

Beyond his formal legal practice, Njiule is deeply committed to leadership, community development, and collaborative teamwork. He demonstrated early leadership as the President of the Students Governing Council at the Kenya School of Law and continues to drive community engagement through pro bono initiatives supporting access to justice in Kajiado County. His multi-faceted leadership skills are also reflected in his social contributions, where he actively serves as the secretary-general of the Kurasa Leadership Society and the Chairman of the Tigers Rugby Club.

This will close in 0 seconds

Francis Kariuki Kinuthia
Director of Operations

 

Francis Kariuki Kinuthia serves as the Director of Operations, where he leads the firm's operational strategy, business processes, and administrative functions to ensure seamless service delivery and sustainable growth. As the driving force behind the firm's operational excellence, he is responsible for optimizing workflows, enhancing efficiency, coordinating cross-functional teams, and ensuring that the firm's strategic objectives are effectively translated into measurable outcomes.

With extensive experience in operations management, project execution, and organizational leadership, Francis brings a unique blend of strategic oversight and hands-on execution to the firm. He oversees internal operations, resource management, performance systems, client support functions, and process improvement initiatives, ensuring that the firm consistently delivers exceptional service while maintaining the highest standards of professionalism and efficiency.

Before joining the firm, Francis served in senior operational leadership roles, including as Director of Operations at Orca Agriculture Company in Israel, where he managed large-scale operations, coordinated multidisciplinary teams, and oversaw the implementation of systems designed to improve productivity, resource utilization, and organizational performance. His international experience provided him with valuable exposure to global best practices in operations management, strategic planning, and business process optimization. He further enhanced his expertise through advanced training at the Arava International Centre in Israel, gaining insights into innovative management systems, operational efficiency models, and large-scale project coordination.

Known for his structured, solutions-oriented, and results-driven approach, Francis works closely with the firm's leadership team to strengthen organizational capacity, improve operational performance, and support the firm's continued growth. His leadership philosophy is grounded in accountability, collaboration, and continuous improvement, ensuring that Hansen Advocates LLP remains agile, efficient, and positioned to meet the evolving needs of its clients.

Away from the office, Francis is a former rugby player and an aspiring professional golfer. The transition from the teamwork and intensity of rugby to the precision and strategy of golf reflects the qualities he brings to leadership, discipline, resilience, focus, and a commitment to continuous growth. Whether driving operational excellence or pursuing personal goals, he approaches every challenge with determination, professionalism, and an unwavering pursuit of excellence.

Email: francis@hansenadvocates.com

This will close in 0 seconds

This will close in 0 seconds

Njiule Wakoli, DPO
Partner 

 

Njiule Wakoli, DPO, is an accomplished Advocate of the High Court of Kenya and a dynamic legal practitioner with extensive experience delivering tailored legal solutions across East Africa. He holds a Bachelor of Laws (LLB) from Mount Kenya University, a Post Graduate Diploma in Law from the Kenya School of Law, and specialized certifications in IP Law from the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and Data Protection from Strathmore University.

Throughout his career, Njiule has built a robust professional background through impactful roles in public and private institutions. He has served as a Bench Legal Researcher at the Rent Restriction Tribunal in Nairobi, a corporate agent and legal assistant at Elegant Investments 1996 Limited, and gained early experience at Chege Kibathi & Co. Advocates and the High Court of Kenya. Notably, he has acted as lead counsel in landmark public interest cases successfully reviewing the jurisdiction of select Kenyan tribunals, and was recognized in 2023 as the best upcoming litigator and debater before Lord Baron Burnett of Maldon, the Chief Justice of England and Wales.

Beyond his formal legal practice, Njiule is deeply committed to leadership, community development, and collaborative teamwork. He demonstrated early leadership as the President of the Students Governing Council at the Kenya School of Law and continues to drive community engagement through pro bono initiatives supporting access to justice in Kajiado County. His multi-faceted leadership skills are also reflected in his social contributions, where he actively serves as the secretary-general of the Kurasa Leadership Society and the Chairman of the Tigers Rugby Club.

This will close in 0 seconds